How to revise your script without losing your mind

Last month, I sat down with writer Amy Reed (Hello Goodbye and Everything in Between, Jingle Bell Heist) for an AMA about something we all struggle with: revision. Amy's worked across every format and genre—features, TV, live-action, animation, rewrites-for-hire, OWAs—and her process insights are in-credible. Here's what stuck with me and stood out to members of our community:

October 30, 2026

10 tips on the messy art of revision from my chat with screenwriter, Amy Reed

Last month, I sat down with writer Amy Reed (Hello Goodbye and Everything in Between, Jingle Bell Heist) for an AMA about something we all struggle with: revision.

Amy's worked across every format and genre—features, TV, live-action, animation, rewrites-for-hire, OWAs—and her process insights are in-credible. Here's what stuck with me and stood out to members of our community:

1. Writing IS revising (the rumors are true)

"All that to say is writing is revising. Everything you're doing is setting up for that process... And the best thing that you can do is sort of like allow yourself to kind of feel okay, mentally, that your writing is going to continue to change. A script is a blueprint. It's gonna change all the way until the final show."

Your first draft isn't (and probably shouldn’t be) your final draft. Once you accept this, the whole process gets less overwhelming. Open yourself to the idea that it will change, and just focus on making the script better.

2. Take a beat before diving into revision

Amy's approach: finish your draft, then step away for a few days. Come back with fresh eyes and ask yourself:

  • How am I feeling reading this?

  • Are the emotional beats hitting the way I want?

  • What's working? What's not?

"Some of these things, you know as you're writing where you're like ‘I'm gonna have to come back and fix this’... but other things, there's— it comes with experience."

Which is to say, keep writing! You’ll get better at this the more you do it. And I truly believe the revision process is where great writers are made, because it trains us to see the full picture of our story and improve our craft little by little. Then you take those lessons into your next script!

3. Lean on your people

"I rely heavily on a trusted network of friends to help me...[Find] the people that are going to be honest with you … that aren't going to make you feel defeated out of it, but encouraged."

Writing is a team sport. Even before your script hits a writers' room or a producer's desk, you need trusted readers who'll be honest without crushing your soul.

4. Read for one problem at a time

Ok I chimed in on this one, but the best advice I can give for revision is to read for one aspect of your story at a time. Don't try to fix everything in one pass. Read through once focusing ONLY on character arcs. Then again for structure. Then for dialogue.

“I just started like only reading for one problem at a time. You end up reading it so many times, but that way, I'm not thinking about changing the whole thing, I'm only thinking about this one character and its character arc. Does that work? And then when you're done, start the next thing. It makes it less overwhelming, I think, if people feel like it's too big a task to look at the entire script at once.”

Breaking revision into focused passes makes the mountain feel more like a series of manageable hills.

5. Similarly, when making big changes to a draft: think like a remodeler

"You're remodeling a house, you know... you're going room by room. And sometimes it means like, you you're tearing down an entire room and building an addition and like going in a different direction."

Don't try to rebuild the entire structure at once. Tackle one section, see how it affects the others, adjust as needed. Tackle revisions based on what will have the biggest effect on the foundation of the house.

6. Keep a "scratch document" for your darlings (the ones you killed)

Before you delete that scene you love (but know doesn't work), paste it into a separate doc. Amy calls this her scratch document—a graveyard for murdered darlings that you might resurrect later.

"I always have something that mentally helps me, I have a scratch document of just, if I'm making major revisions and I'm just cutting scenes or cutting chunks, and it's a little, you know, it's emotional. You're like, ‘I'm killing my darlings.’ I've put them in a scratch document. So, I have it here. If I want to come back to it, I know it exists on this page… there's something about being like, ‘I'm not letting you go. I'm just sort of moving you here for a minute.” And so it gives me the freedom on the actual page to be like, ‘all right, I'm trying something new’"

7. Notes are diagnostic, not prescriptive

"Oftentimes people will give you prescriptive notes... sitting for a second and being like, I don't necessarily have to take the suggested route they’re offering... but thinking about what's not connecting that's making them ask this question. Why are they having this response to X scene and how can I make this clear to achieve whatever my intention is from it"

When someone says "you should do XYZ," they're usually identifying a problem, not prescribing the only solution. Your job is to figure out what's broken and fix it your way.

8. Choose your battles.

Amy's worked on multiple features as a hired gun, and her biggest lesson?

"And, and you have to pick your battles of like, what are the ones that you're like, ‘I want to fight for this. Cause I know that this is going to help the movie’ and try to plead your case and say this is what works. And then there's like the moments where I'm like, ‘Okay, I've tried something, it wasn't for you, we'll move on. And then you have to get used to that ."

Screenwriting always has a lot of cooks in the kitchen, and in features, especially as a writer-for-hire, it's about serving the director's vision and the producers' goals while still bringing your unique flavor to the table. Pick your battles. Not every hill is worth dying on.

9. Make your character’s voices specific

“Especially with like comedy [but with] anything, if you were to black out every name in this script, could you tell who's [saying] each of the lines? It's just a really good way to feel like, okay, how are my voices different? Each individual character, who are they and are they coming across?

At this point, if you have taken any of my classes, you have heard this advice. We both want to extend our thanks to whoever thought of this because it has saved us on more than one occasion. But generally, for the reader and for the audience, we want to be able to distinguish characters easily in your story. In the later stages of revision, consider doing a character voice pass!

10. Her final piece of advice

“Always just write from your heart and what is interesting and good for you. I think when people try to hit a mark and make other people happy is where creativity suffers. And I think if you really stick to what's interesting to you, what's your voice and what is making you excited to go to the page, you will always find a more satisfying result.”

And my last piece of advice is be kind to yourself during revision. Don't be too precious. Trust the process. And remember: every draft is just getting you closer to the version that works.

I loved chatting with Amy, I hope you found this helpful! This was a private event for the SBA community, so if you’d like to watch the full recording, you can join the SBA Society for free here.

Join & Watch The Full Discussion

Now go forth and revise, knowing that even the pros are out here scrambling to figure out Act 2. ⚡

One Resource I made for you is a Revision Survival Guide which guides you through the revision process and provides a structured framework to help you stay organized, and not overwhelmed, during your revisions. Grab it here!

Open Tabs:

ICYMI: Industry Reads

Previous
Previous

Make Your Scenes Work For You

Next
Next

The 4 Step Process to Make Sure You Don't Run Out of Script Ideas